Just pick up insurance on them. Sub due them till the cops arrive and go visit them everyday when in their jail. Keeps you out of jail for attempted murder and gets you a new bike.
True that would be better for here in Ohio, but in Texas where my home is we are legally allowed to use deadly force to recover stolen property. You can even legally shoot someone for just attempting to break into your home so it would definitely be a justified shot if they were already in your garage!
While we are on the subject about stolen bikes, it seems a lot of people are unaware that their garage is one of the most unsecured points in your home. Shoot, people can break into a garage with a clothes hanger as shown in this video. It would pay off to reinforce this area of your home for more security and peace of mind.
<iframe width="420" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/CMz1tXBVT1s" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen=""></iframe>