I mentioned the GOAT as the single best rider on the planet ever, he is the bar to which all other racers are measured against now. You never heard anything about the GOAT winning titles when others were hurt…… people were saying that the GOAT would lose an outdoor title when Bubba got to race against him outside before Bubba actually got there. Guess what, most years Bubba got hurt and wasn't in the racing for the Championship yet no one says if RC wouldn't have won if Bubba was healthy and on the line every week. That's part of this game for the riders, being there to get points week in and week out and win the Championship. RC won every outdoor title contest he entered for the complete series. The only one he didn't win was when he was semi retired and riding only half the events on his farewell tour……. and that doesn't count as a loss.
And Yes, Kroc is out with injury, but hurting himself in a hasty decision isn't Dungey's fault. Kroc was in this series and took himself out of it. Dungey is the best we have at the moment in SX, it's clear by the points standings that he is the top dog.
I agree, Villopoto and McGrath were more dominant SX riders than Dungey. Outdoors, RC, Bubba for one season, and Villopoto were more dominant that Dungey there too. But Dungey is in elite company when talking titles and wins for a racer and you can't take that away from him no matter what.